The key elements essential for delivering engaging Radio ads have been confirmed in the results from Engaging Emotions Through Effective Radio Ads, the second part of a study from the Radio Ad Lab conducted by Gallup & Robinson (G&R).
Highlights from the study:
• Strong beginnings make a difference. An involving point of entry distinguishes some of the most successful Radio ads.
• Word selection matters. Words that are sensory-laden, emotional, or empowering have a demonstrable impact on the emotional reactions of consumers.
• Audio can be powerful. Audio can generate stronger emotions than visuals, especially when the tonality in the ad is used effectively.
• Brand mentions have an impact. The best Radio ads mention the advertiser’s brand multiple times, strategically placed to correlate with moments of high consumer engagement.
The highest scoring and best performing ad in the study exhibited all of the above, a strong indication that Radio commercials are highly engaging to consumers when the creative process follows these patterns.
Engaging Emotions Through Effective Radio Ads measured moment-by-moment physiological reactions to Radio ads to distinguish which creative elements delivered the best performing commercials. The full research paper, featuring links to the audio of the ads and the accompanying panograms that illustrate the emotional reactions, are available here.
The original 2007 Engagement, Emotions, and the Power of Radio study used G&R’s Continuous Emotional Response Analysis (CERA) to measure emotional activation at a deep, pre-cognitive level with Facial Electromyography (EMG) for 16 real campaigns. The study found that on average, radio ads have emotional impact on consumers that is equal to that of television ads.
For the second phase of the study, Engaging Emotions Through Effective Radio Ads, the Radio Ad Lab examined moment-by-moment reactions to the same Radio ads. While not a comprehensive survey of all possible creative techniques, they were able to distinguish which creative elements delivered the best performing commercials, based on positive EMG scores.
Pattern #1: Strong Beginnings Make a Difference
Several of the higher-rated ads included an involving point of entry, often beginning strongly with something that hooked listeners emotionally from the first seconds of the ad. A 60-second Allstate ad promoting their “accident forgiveness” program was one of the three highest-scoring Radio ads based on G&R’s positive EMG measure (120.2). It was also one of the Radio ads that showed a statistically significant difference from its television counterpart.
The ad engaged listeners from the outset with a very personal and important question: “If you have an accident, did you know your insurance rates could go up by 40%?”
Pattern #2: Spoken Words Are Powerful
The specific words used in ads can make a real difference. And in Radio, the power of the spoken word can be impressive when those words are sensory-laden, emotional, or empowering. The Radio ad for Campbell’s Chunky Soup, part of the well-known Mama McNabb campaign, scored just as well as its TV counterpart. Sensory-laden phrases like “Chunky Fajita Steak Soup…loaded with big chunks of steak,” combined with the announcer’s delivery, clearly broke through with spikes in emotional reactions after the midpoint of the ad.
Pattern #3: Advertiser Branding = Brand Recall
They saw a clear correlation between brand recall and the number of brand mentions in their set of ads. "While we’d never advocate “number of brand mentions” as a singular goal for copy writing, brand mentions are important for successful ads. In Radio, effective branding and emotional effectiveness can go hand in hand." The full paper presents a Radio ad for the Audi A-Series cars that managed to weave nine separate Audi mentions into 60 seconds, and most occurred during high levels of emotional engagement.
Note: Brand mentions can sometimes get lost when audio tracks are simply lifted from television ads for use as Radio commercials. A television ad may have depended on both visual and audio cues for branding, but when the audio track is simply transferred to Radio, all of those visual-only branding opportunities disappear.
Pattern #4: Sustain Interest Throughout
The ads that sustained interest throughout the commercial had the best overall positive EMG scores, as exemplified in the Allstate and Campbell’s charts. The Allstate ad, for example, maintained positive EMG scores at or above the average Radio ad score except for the “boilerplate” section toward the end.
Pattern #5: Doing It All Well Is Powerful
Ads that utilize all of these elements can have the greatest impact. An Oscar Mayer Radio ad—part of the well-known “My bologna has a first name” series—was the highest scoring overall, with a Positive EMG score of 121.9, and an unaided recall score of 61%.
The ad contained all of the essential principles outlined above:
Strong beginning — the positive emotional reactions are high right from the start.
Colorful, sensory language — “…a happy lunch…quality meat…no fillers.”
Effective branding — the Oscar Mayer jingle is one big brand reference.
Sustained interest — a consistent, above-average performance throughout.